Football and Coaching- #1 Meeting Place for Football Coaches on the Internet

How do you decide to have a running game based on a zone running scheme or a man running scheme?Lets look at the pros and cons of each scheme.

A zone running scheme is one in which the linemen have a gap blocking scheme and the runningback usually runs to an area and has cutback lanes to choose from.

Pros:

1. Allows the Offensive Linemen the ability to adapt to any defensive front.
2. Teamwork is more of an emphasis for the line as they have to work together in order to get to the linebackers.
3. Cut back lanes are created for runningbacks.
4. Great against aggressive defenses that fly to the ball.

Cons:

1. A lot more emphasis is on coaching and teaching fundamentals of blocking.
2. Footwork is key to great running which takes time and repetition.
3. Need the right type of running back  that has good to great vision of the field that can see the cut back lanes.
4. Runningback also needs to have the patience o allow the blocks to develop.

The man blocking scheme is the more traditional one of the two. it is the one that majority of coaches grew up learning and playing. It is based on the theory that each man has his block and it is up to him to win the battle. Usually the center sets the blocking by designating if he is covered or not. This scheme is more designed for the type or back that has power and can run people over.

Pros:

1.  The offense can wear down the defense very quickly if the scheme is successful.
2. The Line does not need to know much, just to know what number they have to block based on the Centers call.
3. Showcases a brusing back and does not require much coaching for either the line or backs.
4. Blocking is very aggressive and really sets the tone for the game.

Cons:

1. By deisgnating the block based on the Centers call, there is very little room for adaptability if the defense shifts before the snap.
2. Very easy for an aggressive defense to load up the box and out number the offensive linemen at the point of attack.
3. Very little room for cutback lanes to develop based on blocking.
4. This is the cornerstone of every offense, so every defense will be prepared for it.
5. Puts pressure on the line to be biggest and very individual both on and off the field.

I know I forgot some pros and cons for each, but that is the list that I came up with. For me I would go with both a man and  zone scheme. I would take the good from both and make my own.  Fo me though, most lines are under developed and do not have the chance get ot the weightroom. Given that I would try and focus on a zone attack with the time spent with the runningbacks teaching them how to read the blocks.